by Josh
Here's a note about a topic I hold very close to my heart.
It's in regards to the movie that has completely caught my attention, and if you follow my Facebook, it needs no introduction.
That's right. A painstakingly long note on my review of Scott Pilgrim vs. The World.
I'd like to add that this wouldn't be possible if not for Paulie Walnuts. His combating my own starstruck initial perceptions of the movie forced me to take the film for what it is and look at it differently.
First off, the plot is simple, but original (to a degree). Scott Pilgrim meets his (literal) dream girl, Ramona Flowers. The two hit it off, but in order for them to date, he must defeat all seven of her Evil Exes. The film in itself is the big screen adaptation of the graphic novel series Scott Pilgrim. Having read all six novels, I rented the DVD with some guy friends and tried to keep my inner critic out of the room for a couple hours.
I'm going to cover my review in seven sections, mostly gravitated around each Evil Ex:
1.) From the very beginning of the movie, a lot of promises are made to the audience. We know that a fusion of video game, comic book, and conventional movie is attempted here, and the visuals are amazing. The fight with the first Evil Ex, Matthew Patel, gets us primed for more and I'm ready.
2.) Comparing book to movie, the differences here aren't noteworthy regarding the fight with Lucas Lee. However, at about this point in the books, a bit of backstory is revealed regarding Scott and Kim Pine. I felt that this was needed; instead, Kim comes off as kind of a broken-hearted girl creeping on Scott from the shadows. Her character is much deeper than that. The one-liners and the quirkiness of the characters let me forgive this, however.
3.) Story stays pretty accurate here in the fight against Todd Ingram. Vegan psychic, Envy, Scott almost dying...all here. An interesting change is that Scott doesn't get his extra life here: that happens against the Twins much later. We also don't see how Todd cheats on Envy; this side-plot was important for developing Envy as first a source of heartache for Scott, and later, a refuge for when he is dumped by Ramona. Also, there is a battle where Knives and Ramona fight against Envy, and almost lose.
The bass battle is pretty cool, though.
4.) This is where the movie loses momentum at an alarming rate. In the books, Scott and Ramona move in together and Scott gets a job with Stephen. We see none of this, and we don't see Scott try to pick himself up out of his slacker life. Instead, we're treated to an immediate fight after Todd with Roxie. I wanted to cringe when she screamed that she was a little "BI-FURIOUS!!!!!" not because of its cliche, but for how they portrayed her character. I swear I've met the real-life version of Roxie at every college campus I've visited...
Anyway, lots of details get melded here. The party was supposed to be for the Katanyagi Twins. The back-of-knee weak spot was a weakness of Envy's, not Roxie's. And Mr. Chau, Knives' father, isn't even in the script (a Ninja Gaiden-style battle takes place with Scott/Ramona vs. Roxie/Mr. Chau). Lots of holes are getting riddled in the script due to negligence...and Scott gets his Power of Love Sword here, not against Gideon.
5 and 6.) This is the Evil Ex fight that I had the most problems with. The Katanyagi Twins are straight badasses in the book. They have robots that fight their battles, and they actually speak and go into depth as to how Ramona hurt the both of them. Instead, we're introduced to Gideon before the Twins "fight" Scott (the movie fight is a battle of the bands with the Twins vs. Sex Bob-omb), and the Twins fall in, like, 3 minutes.
7.) I was in love with the scenes with Gideon and hated them at the same time. I loved the action, and loved the swordplay. I hated the fight with Ramona and Knives, and equally hated Scott/Knives vs. Gideon. This was a total creative betrayal of the relationship this movie sought to establish with Scott and Ramona. Also, not much explanation is given as to how Gideon is this powerful or how he got the chip on Ramona; in the novels, she had this chip on her all along.
What details were missed that this movie needed?:
-Stephen turning gay/working at the Happy Avocado, an area where Scott works...character development.
-Scott's wilderness sabbatical with Kim Pine, where he fights and merges with Nega-Scott.
-Ramona isn't even involved in the final fight between Scott and Gideon; she herself is in the woods at her father's cabin while all this happens.
-Backstory discussing Kim, Stephen, Wallace, and Envy.
-Gideon dates Envy near the end of the movie, not Ramona.
Having said all this...this movie was definitely for the fans or the mildly curious. I legitimately love this movie anyway, because it reaches out to a side of myself I wish I could achieve. Nerdy guys, isn't it one of the most epic things we can do, to fight for the dream girl on our terms? Scott Pilgrim gets this. How about music skills? Bass guitar. Video game styled combat and sound effects? Hell yeah.
But the real message I got from this movie is this: she's out there. You can love if you be yourself. That's a damn good message.
The delivery definitely was a creative answer I've been seeking forever in at least one movie, and the people from my generation will love this.
Also, comparing levels of badassery, here's where I'd rank the Evil Exes as far as legitimate danger (with 7 being the highest):
1. Matthew Patel: Despite this guy being a total pansy, he actually was probably the most believable Evil Ex (besides Lucas Lee). Plus, he's the first one we see in the trailers. "MISTER PILGRIM!!!!!1111!one!!!1!1!"
2. Roxie Richter: I kind of felt like the bisexual stereotype was played too heavily in the movie for her. Nevertheless, both Scott and Ramona team up to defeat her. Weak.
3. Katanyagi Twin: See below.
4. Katanyagi Twin: If only their robot skills were used in the movie...but they weren't, and a creative outlet was totally missed here.
5. Lucas Lee: Action star, stunt team...
6. Todd Ingram: psychic powers? He could've torn Scott in half with his MIND. He blew a hole in the moon, for crying out loud. But instead he flings Scott and throws him through a few walls.
7. Gideon Graves: He's the archvillain for a reason. I actually liked Jason Schwartzman's portrayal of Gideon; I felt it was pretty accurate.
On a nerd scale, I give this movie a 10/10.
On a critical scale, I give it a 6.5 out of 10.
....that averages out to a B grade. And that's not bad.
I'm getting the DVD soon. After I watch it a million times, I'm gonna get to work finding my own Ramona Flowers.
-Josh